Melissa on April 26th, 2009

In my last article, “Why Do We Need To Take Supplements”, we discussed the importance of taking natural supplements to support our body and our immune system.  But which supplements do we take and how do we know which supplements are the best ones?  With billions being spent every year on supplements, it is very important you understand that not all supplements are created equal….there are sometimes very vast differences between one product and another. 

So let’s talk about the difference between “Whole Food Based” and “Synthetic or Isolated or Fractionated” Supplements.  A great example would be just to simply look at almost any Multi-Vitamin.  When you scan the nutritional content fact and ingredient label, you’ll see quite an assortment of vitamins….Vitamin A, Vitamin C, Vitamin E, etc.  Here is a portion of a label from a common multi-vitamin:

commonvitlabel1

Now obviously there are alot more vitamins listed on this label than I had room for, but I think you get the idea.  Specifically, I want you to pay attention to the items listed under “Ingredients”.  Those are what we call “Isolated” vitamins and other “chemicals”.  There are no foods or herbal ingredients listed; only partial vitamins and other chemicals.  Nature intended for us to consume food in its WHOLE form because all the vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and enzymes are together in one package and work synergistically together to bring your body the nutrition that it needs.  When you take one part away from the whole, you get “Synthetic”, “Isolated” or “Fractionated” pieces of the whole, but it is simply not the same.   The other problem is that by taking isolated vitamins, sometimes we are getting “massive” doses of some vitamins, but not enough of others.   Over time, this can cause health problems too and aren’t we trying to get healthy rather than cause more problems?

Whole-Food based supplements are different.  Typically, they will list the foods that the supplement was made from.  Here is an example of what to look for when searching for a Whole-Food based product.  Notice that under the supplemental facts, you’ll still see all the Vitamins listed, but see the difference under the Ingredients….now, there is actual WHOLE food listed:

wholelabel

What a difference this 2nd product will make in your body vs. the first product!  You’ll actually be gaining benefits from the WHOLE food and all of the vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and enzymes that occur naturally in the food or plant. 

Another way that might make sense is to look at the source.  When it says “Vitamin C” on the label, what is the source of that Vitamin C?  What you want to see listed in the ingredient list is the foods; i.e., Citrus Fruits, Papaya, Bell Peppers, etc.  If you see “Ascorbic Acid” listed, that means it is an “Isolated” product.  Keep searching for one that lists the whole foods.

In summary, be sure you read your labels!  It is important to educate yourself about what you’ll be putting into your body and supplements are no different than anything else.   In one of my prior articles, “Reading Food Labels”, we discussed the importance of reading the labels on the foods you’re eating, but it’s just as important if not more so, to be sure you’re reading all of your supplemental labels!  You want to be consuming supplements that have actual whole food, plants or herbs listed on the label; that way you know it is as close to natural as possible!  And lastly, understand that no supplement alone will help you achieve the level of health you desire….you will have to make lifestyle and behavior changes AND take supplements in order to achieve ultimate health.

Tags: , ,

3 Responses to ““Whole-Food” vs. “Synthetic” Supplements”

  1. Dr. Wood,
    What do you think of supplements made by Standard Process? An MD who practices more natural medicine (who has helped me a lot in the last two years) does not think highly of them because he has asked for a not received scientific data to demonstrate that their products are indeed “food” and are as pure and natural as they claim. He says “show me the proof and I’ll believe”. What do you think?
    Thank you,
    David

  2. Hi David, Thanks for writing! I’m glad that you’ve found an MD who is more open-minded and working with more natural medicines. I’ve been using the Standard Process line of whole-food supplements for over 8 years now. I assume when you ask about “scientific data” that he probably is referring to studies. That is a very popular thing for most MD’s to want to look at and unfortunately, most nutritional supplement companies don’t often have studies because the pharmaceutical companies do not underwrite them. There are some studies out there; but I’m sure they would not measure up to what he is specifically looking for.

    For me, the studies do not matter. The fact that company is the most successful (and the oldest) nutritional company in the world, matters to me. The fact that there are literally thousands of patients worldwide that have greatly benefited from these products, matters to me. The fact that I have hundreds and hundreds of clients that I’ve used these products with, that have had significant results, matters to me. I can read the label and clearly see whole-food based products; there are no synthetic or fractionated vitamins/minerals here (unlike most health-food store brands). Those are the things that matter to me. Of course also the fact that there are no side affects and hundreds of thousands of people don’t die from these products every year (unlike pharmaceuticals).

    I wonder if he has been to their home office and had a tour of their facilities to see how their farming and manufacturing processes measure up? I would encourage him to take a trip or to get in touch with one of their representatives in your local area that could educate him about the products. Their other line, Medi-Herb, are strictly herbal products that come from Australia. Australia has significantly more stringent requirements than we have in the US; therefore that particular line of Standard Process products are even more superior than the general SP line.

    I realize most MD’s have an inadequate nutritional background. It is common knowledge that they aren’t adequately trained in nutrition while in med school. That may not be the case with your doctor, but I know for some MD’s, Standard Process products can be a bit intimidating since they don’t feel that they can adequately recommend them. It’s just simpler and easier to recommend a drug, which of course they do know more about. But Standard Process has an extensive training program and ongoing education to educate the doctors, chiropracters and naturopaths that would like to learn more about nutrition. Again, I would encourage him to look into it further, before passing on it altogether.

    Thanks again for writing, David. I hope I’ve answered your question and wish you continued good health!
    Melissa

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Why Choose Alternative Medicine? | Stay Healthy and Well

Leave a Reply